Update (8:50 pm) : Happily, I can now announce that Xtra! editor Danny Glennwright has personally apologized to Lexi, and Lexi has accepted his apology. As a result, we are now calling off the boycott entirely.
Click here for further details.
******************************************************************
Update (7:30 pm) : It’s heartening to see that some much-needed dialogue in the queer community has already been produced around this incident, within the span of a single day. I think the comments on this blog post speak to how important and necessary that dialogue really is. The fact is that the trans community occupies some funny space in the larger queer and trans community. While I have little interest in the calls some make for trans separation from the larger queer community, it has to be acknowledged that there is a real history of disrespect and even exploitation of trans people, and that history must be addressed.
Regarding the boycott call itself, we are presently waiting for some further developments around the issue. In the meantime, those of us who proposed the boycott have been overwhelmed by the level of support that has been offered from both within and outside the trans community.
All of us, including Lexi, are overwhelmed by your support and your kindness.
******************************************************************
Original Post (1 pm):
The trans community has a long history of disrespect coming from mainstream media sources, including mainstream gay and lesbian news outlets. This includes, for example, acts of intentionally misgendering trans individuals, revealing someone’s trans status without their permission, and printing their birth name without permission. These types of disrespect go hand-in-hand with a history of trans exploitation, in which a trans person’s story is presented in a sensationalistic manner in order to sell copy cheap and quick.
Recently, Canada’s primary queer news outlet Xtra! was fortunate enough to be given the opportunity to interview Toronto local trans icon Lexi Tronic for a larger story on the dangers of sex work in Canada. The story itself (by my friend Andrea Houston) is well-written and respectful, relating the very real difficulties that sex workers– including trans sex workers– face on a regular basis, especially focusing on the fact that Canadian law as it presently stands serves to stigmatize their lives and make sex workers more vulnerable to violence and exploitation.
Unfortunately, that is not where the story ends. While the story itself was written in a respectful manner, the editor Danny Glenwright chose to discuss the story on his Facebook wall by publicly referring to Tronic by her birth name. Apparently he claims that because it’s not technically part of the story itself, it’s acceptable for to do so. This claim childishly ignores the fact that the story and what the editor of the paper say about it publicly are largely inseparable to the public at large (and yes Facebook counts as public, especially in a tight-knit community like Toronto’s queer community). Glenwright has been confronted about the issue and he has refused to apologize.
The fact is that Glenwright’s actions serve to insult Tronic (and the trans community as a whole) and to publicly attempt to undermine her gender identity, especially after she graciously lent her trust to Xtra in agreeing to be interviewed. Hence, myself and others are now calling for a boycott on Xtra until Glenwright apologizes for his actions. Further, he should come forward publicly to describe that it is unacceptable to misgender a trans person or use their birth name without permission under any circumstances.Finally, on a personal note, I will say that Lexi is a friend of mine and a local hero in the trans community. She does charity work, for example raising money for the needs of our fellow trans community members. She’s also a really beautiful person inside and out, and she doesn’t deserve to be treated this way.
Mr. Glenwright, apologize immediately.


16 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 13, 2011 at 2:05 pm
elisha lim
Is there a petition? Where do I sign?
December 13, 2011 at 7:10 pm
leftytgirl
The idea is that a group of us would refuse to comment for stories in Xtra! until the issue is resolved. We are presently waiting for developments.
December 13, 2011 at 2:22 pm
alagarconniere
sadly not the first time xtra has fucked up in situations like this. we need to hold them accountable. great post!
December 13, 2011 at 3:51 pm
JS
Curious, Xtra sells their access to the Trans community to advertisers who pay the paper to have their advertisements seen by members of the Trans community. Yet the paper refuses to include the community in its mission: “the gay and lesbian press.”
So why is the Trans community good enough to produce ad revenue via advertising for Xtra, yet not good enough to be included in their mission?
What kind of message does this send?
December 13, 2011 at 4:10 pm
Leslea
Time to man up Mr Glenwright. Apologize & stop being such a douche.
December 13, 2011 at 4:17 pm
Rita Gonzales
this goes beyond reporting and is an infringement on privacy. it is more info than the story needs to give. much more than an apology needed here.
December 13, 2011 at 5:41 pm
sav durham
How can we write a letter to xtra?
December 13, 2011 at 7:13 pm
leftytgirl
Xtra’s contact page:
http://www.xtra.ca/public/national/staticontent/89.aspx
December 13, 2011 at 6:04 pm
John
Apologies are great, but are super easy to fake for the sake of media. I’ve been boycotting Xtra for a few years now, and this only adds to the injury they’ve caused the community they claim to serve (even though it’s still technically a Gay and Lesbian newspaper, they do touch on trans issues, usually with devastating results).
Until I see drastic action to change the values and expectations of its writers, editors and anyone else who works on the paper, I’m going to keep boycotting them.
This is unacceptable.
December 13, 2011 at 6:27 pm
Vanessa C
Xtra has done similar before, it’s not just Glenwright. He has to step down, as does the whole board for allowing this. Xtra has in the past done similar actions that were disrespectful to the trans community (and to be honest, some downright HATEFUL actions too in the past!). I haven’t picked up a copy of Xtra since 2001, and will never until they change their statement to also include trans and other gender diversities.
December 13, 2011 at 9:51 pm
Chris R
What do you mean when you say. “misgender a trans person”? Is that referring to them by a gender other than they one they wish to be referred by? Logic tells me that’s it, but I’m just making sure. Also, Lexi Tronic – awesome name.
December 13, 2011 at 11:06 pm
leftytgirl
Hi Chris, yes you have it exactly right! Misgendering means referring to someone as “he/him” when in fact that person identifies as a woman and prefers female pronouns, or vice versa. It is always inappropriate to misgender anyone, including trans folk. And yes, Lexi Tronic is a cool name!
December 13, 2011 at 10:45 pm
LJS
one’s birth name is a part of one’s history, not a shameful secret to be hidden. But of course, people should be primarily using a person’s current name when referring to the individual.
December 13, 2011 at 11:10 pm
leftytgirl
The main point is that the person in question should have the choice of whether to divulge their birth name or not. There are all kinds of complicated issues (beyond any question of shame) that could potentially arise. Trans people have been fired from their job or even suffered violence resulting from other individuals giving out their personal information.
December 15, 2011 at 6:12 am
sdyue
black label all disclosures: if you tell, don’t blame us for you getting taunted, outed, exposed, or beat to a pulp by those in your past, present, or potential future.
Fact is, plenty of trans folks will disclose information without realizing full long term impact, that could be dangerous, given the nature of animosity towards trans folks in our current society. We cannot encourage it, just so the media can sell ad space, make a fast buck on sensational tidbits for mass consumption, be it on Xtra, or FB, or other web-public arenas.
December 15, 2011 at 11:12 am
leftytgirl
Sorry, not sure if I totally understood your comment or not. The point is that it is up to an individual trans person to understand their own position, their own vulnerabilities, and what information they are comfortable with being present in the public eye. So if an individual trans person chooses to disclose something (i.e. a birth name) then that is up to the individual.
However, just because one trans individual is comfortable with revealing that, doesn’t imply that all trans persons should have that forced on them (so if trans person A reveals their birth name to a publication, that does NOT make it okay for that publication to dig up or release the birth name of trans person B).
It’s pretty straight-forward really, show some common courtesy and defer to the individual when you aren’t sure.